Controversial complaint against Rep. Matt Gaetz filed by activist Chaz Stevens dismissed by Florida Bar
Tallahassee, Florida – The Florida Bar has dropped a criminal complaint against Representative Matt Gaetz (R-FL), concerning claims of s*x trafficking and interactions with a minor. This ruling came after a careful assessment revealing inadequate evidence of any illegal action.
Originally filed by South Florida activist Chaz Stevens in late September, the case has caused a lot of debate given Stevens’ controversial public character and past of politically and religiously contentious activity. Stevens’ complaint focused on claimed personal wrongdoing rather than closely matching Gaetz’s professional behavior as a lawyer.
Legal professionals such as Miami defense attorney Brian Tannebaum have emphasized the complex factors the Florida Bar has to balance in such circumstances.
“The Bar makes judgment calls. They’ll look at something and say: Yes, it’s a violation, but do we really want to go into this? This is not about arguing a legal bill or dealing with a constituent. This is personal conduct … but isn’t this guy in Congress? Are we dipping into an issue regarding politics?” said Brian Tannebaum as reported by The Floridan Press.
Read also: City of Destin addresses alarming veteran suicide rates with proactive community training initiative
The Bar’s ruling was significantly influenced by the lack of a concurrent criminal inquiry or prosecution. Another defense attorney, David Rothman, explained the rarity of the Bar punishing claims of criminal behavior without a related criminal prosecution.
“[Gaetz] could be sanctioned. But it’s very rare that a criminal conduct allegation against a lawyer winds up being a Bar case without an attendant criminal investigation and prosecution.
The Florida Bar highlighted in their dismissal letter that disciplinary action for criminal behavior calls for a court with relevant authority to prove that the attorney in question really committed a crime.
Rep. Gaetz maintained his innocence throughout the investigation, while presenting proof that he and his family were targets of an extortion campaign run by former DOJ official David McGee. Along with the minor linked to the accusations against Gaetz, whom Gaetz said was influenced by Joel Greenberg, this narrative also claimed included convicted offender Greenberg.
Although the Florida Bar’s closing of this matter marks a turning point in the continuous narrative of Gaetz’s alleged misbehavior, it does not necessarily absolve all investigation on his activities. Reflecting the complicated interaction of law, politics, and public opinion that this case represents, the public and legal analysts will probably continue to closely monitor any developments as usual.