By Chris Leavenworth
People tend to be uncomfortable with the notion that free will is an illusory construct. I’ve had discussions with people who have gotten legitimately angry in their defense of a concept for which they could not provide substantial evidence. Many people hinge their whole worldview on free will, and to lose it, they fear, would be to pull the rug out from under their lifelong values.
For the religious, denying free will implies that man has no real choice in his own sin, and yet he still must answer to God for his fixed transgressions. For the ones who find comfort in control, denying free will implies that we are all ultimately powerless to our nature and external circumstances. To the dualist, it implies that our identity is completely physical. To the egomaniac, it implies a great deal of humility.
To a Rush fan, it means Geddy Lee’s poetic lyrics for one of their best tracks is about an existential fantasy. That was the hump I had to get over.
People hold onto the idea of an inner-arbiter, the type that manifests its own unique set of values and characteristics on carbon-based life forms and calls all the shots. This could accurately be called DNA. Despite the evidence, simplicity and beauty of its implications, for most people, DNA isn’t a satisfactory answer.
Every decision a person makes, for better or for worse, begins as a thought.
If we’re willing to admit that a thought doesn’t arise in a vacuum, and that the outcome of a thought depends, at the very least, on the overall condition of the brain making the thought, and its predispositions based on prior and present experiences, how much room is really left for free will?
One of the most common leaps people make when defending free will is that if it doesn’t exist, and all our choices and actions are inescapable, then crime shouldn’t be punished and no one can be held accountable for their actions. Even if that was true—that no one is truly liable for their decisions because they can’t possibly be avoided—I don’t see how it then proves free will. It would just mean we’re going about things awfully wrong.
I don’t believe that to be the case, though. If someone breaks the law or hurts somebody else, they should be held accountable. If a person cannot deviate from the bad choices or actions they’re determined to make, it’s not a reason to assume we all want to live in a world where it’s tolerated. Anyone that can appreciate a civilized society should understand the sense in that.
Although it’s necessary that crime be punished, it never truly corrects the wrong to a victim, and rarely does it prevent the offender from committing the crime again. Promoting better circumstances for people to not commit crime in the first place would seem much more favorable than waiting around for crime to happen.
Recognizing that crime, just like everything else, is determined by fixed circumstances that can be altered leads to improved conclusions about how to prevent it. This can be said about most all human behavior and tendencies. Understanding the conditions and factors that influence thoughts can greatly improve a person’s potential to make better decisions, form better habits, and live a healthier and happier lifestyle.
- Gulfarium Unveils New Dune Walk
- News from the Gumbo World – Throwdowns and Fresh Starts
- NWF State College Techies Honored
It’s Not Augusta National
By Charles Morgan III The beach that runs the length of the Panhandle of Florida was once known for its soft, snow-white sand. It is now getting recognition for the threatening...
The music-loving portion of the Beachcomber community—most of us, I’d say—got some devastating news early in the week when we learned that the talented young vocalist Buddy Brumit died in an automobile...
Towne: The Records That Changed Our Lives
Jon Decious: While there must be at least 100 records that have changed my life, looking back I think Garth Brooks’ Ropin’ the Wind might be the one responsible (to blame) for...
NOW OPEN SEED LIBRARY Walton County Coastal Branch Library, Santa Rosa Beach 850-267-2809 The library welcomes the community to participate in the “Community Seed Library” located next to the New Books section....
VS. – The Battle of Record Store Day 2019
A new feature, in which two Beachcomberland entities face off, and it’s up to our highly biased judges to declare a victor. Record Store Day (Saturday, April 13 worldwide) was conceived...
Thursday, April 11 AJ’S, Destin WILL & LINDA, 4-8 PM (Bimini Stage) CHASING JAYMIE, 6-10 PM (Tiki Stage) REDSHIRT FRESHMAN (Bimini Stage) AJ’S ON THE BAYOU, Fort Walton Beach CHRIS HAYES, 5-9 PM AL’S BEACH...